Most SEO agencies sell businesses the same package they sold five years ago: keyword research, content calendars, monthly backlink reports, and a quarterly strategy review. That package was fine in 2020, when Google was the only search channel that mattered for most businesses. It's not fine anymore.
The search landscape has fragmented. Google is still the biggest single channel, but ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Grok, Gemini, Copilot, and Meta AI now collectively handle a growing share of the queries that used to go exclusively to Google. An SEO agency that only optimizes for Google is optimizing for yesterday's search behavior — and charging today's prices for it.
The foundation hasn't changed. Keyword strategy informed by search volume and competitive difficulty. Technical audits that catch crawl errors, broken links, and performance issues. Content optimization that balances readability with search intent. Backlink building through legitimate outreach and digital PR. Local SEO including Google Business Profile management. Analytics and reporting that connect SEO activity to business outcomes. Any agency worth hiring does this well.
Can AI crawlers access your site? What's your robots.txt configuration for GPTBot, ClaudeBot, and PerplexityBot? Is your structured data formatted for LLM extraction, or just for Google rich snippets? Do you have an llms.txt file? What does ChatGPT actually say when someone asks about your industry in your city? If your agency can't answer these questions with data — not opinions — they're only covering half the search landscape.
Beyond auditing, you need actual deliverables. Not a PDF saying "add schema markup." The actual schema code, written for your business. Not a recommendation to "update your robots.txt." The actual robots.txt file, configured for all 8 AI crawler user agents. Not a suggestion to "create FAQ content." The actual FAQ schema with questions and answers targeting the queries people ask AI about your industry.
Monthly reporting shouldn't just show Google rankings anymore. It should show your AI recommendation frequency across all 7 major platforms. It should benchmark you against competitors on AI visibility, not just Google position. It should track changes in AI platform behavior and alert you when your visibility shifts — because AI platforms update their models and crawlers more frequently than Google updates its algorithm.
Here's the uncomfortable truth for many agencies: a significant portion of GEO work can be automated. The technical audit, the deliverable generation, the multi-platform monitoring, the competitive benchmarking — these are systematic processes that software handles more consistently, more quickly, and more affordably than manual agency work.
Faneros was built to deliver agency-quality GEO output through software. The Visibility plan ($99/month) handles monitoring that agencies charge thousands for. The Optimization plan ($399/month) generates the full 18-deliverable package. The Agency plan ($1,999/month) adds hands-on implementation for businesses that want white-glove service — still less than most agency retainers.
Not what they think it might say. Not a theoretical analysis. The actual response ChatGPT generates when someone asks for a recommendation in your industry and city. If they can't demo this in real time during your meeting, they're not monitoring AI visibility. They're guessing.
A number, backed by methodology. If they don't have a scoring framework — one that evaluates crawler access, structured data, llms.txt, security signals, and content structure — they're not systematically measuring your AI readiness. They might be doing individual checks, but without a composite methodology, they can't prioritize fixes or track improvement over time.
If the answer is "recommendations in a monthly report," that's not implementation — that's an opinion you're paying for. Ask to see a sample deliverable. Ask for a robots.txt file they've generated. Ask for a JSON-LD schema they've written. If the deliverables are paragraphs of advice rather than deployable code and files, you're paying agency rates for consulting output.
Good agencies will evolve. The best ones are already adding GEO capabilities alongside traditional SEO. But the learning curve is steep, the tooling is new, and most agencies are still in the early stages of building this competency. In the meantime, your business needs AI visibility now — not when your agency catches up.
The most effective approach today: keep your agency for what they do well (traditional SEO, content strategy, link building, local optimization). Add Faneros for what they can't do yet (AI visibility monitoring, GEO deliverables, cross-platform benchmarking). Together, you get human strategic thinking plus automated GEO precision.
AI visibility monitoring from $99/month. 18 ready-to-deploy deliverables. 7 platforms. No contracts.
See Plans & Pricing →